Black Saturday: Methodology and Sources

The present page describes the research methodology followed to reconstruct the two historical narratives on the events of Black Saturday, and lists sources used.

Research Methodology

The Truth and Reconciliation Lebanon project is an effort towards reconciliation by means of historiography. Rather than approaching Lebanon's history from an objectivist perspective, seeking to discover "what really happened," we recognize that every historical narrative is biased and told from a specific perspective. Furthermore, since historical narratives in Lebanon are highly contested among communities, the problem of objective history is significantly exacerbated.

Therefore, our approach is to write history by reconstructing the multiple narratives on events, each of which recognizably represents a community's memory and experience of the events in question.We also recognize that even a single community does not have a single narrative, and that furthermore communities do not have tight boundaries.

While leaving open the question as to how many narratives would need to be written on Black Saturday, we started out with the assumption that we would end up with two narratives, one Palestinian/Muslim/Left-Wing (National Movement), the other Kataeb/Christian/Right-Wing (Lebanese Front), though neither fitting these labels perfectly. This assumption derives from the two sides that are generally considered to have been fighting each other at this point in the Civil War.

The research process that led to the present narratives followed the following steps:

  1. Archival research on 6 left- and right-wing newspapers through articles dealing with Black Saturday in the days of its aftermath (see sources below).
  2. Documentary research on 9 writings of primary witnesses or knowledgeable actors at the time (see sources below).
  3. Production of the first drafts of two narratives based on the above research.
  4. Interviews with 6 primary witnesses - actors and survivors from both the National Movement and Lebanese Front - to verify the draft narratives and obtain further perspectives, including visits to purported sites of the Fanar incident. The location as depicted on the map is the one pointed out by primary witnesses closest to the events.
  5. Interviews with 5 gatekeepers of the narratives to verify how well the draft narratives represent today's collective memory. These people are gatekeepers by virtue of their well-established status in the different parties involved. They were party members at the time, but not on the ground during Black Saturday.
  6. Finalizing the narratives, giving precedence to the accounts of primary witnesses, while indicating where diversity of perspectives within the same community exists.

These narratives have subsequently been used in focus group discussions among Lebanese of different age groups and allegiances to test their effectiveness as a tool for reconciliation.

Bibliography

  1. Abou Zahr, Hisham. Publisher. “The Ugly Massacre Shakes Lebanon. The Kataeb criminals moved, led by Bashir Gemayel ... the killing, kidnapping and shooting began.” Al-Muharrir. Sunday 7th December 1975. Year 14, number 3961.
  2. Al-Lawzi, Salim. Ed. “If the Syrians and Kataeb agree, is there anything left for others?” Al-Hawadess. Friday 12th December 1975. Year 20. Number 996.
  3. Omaira, George. Ed. “A Sudden Deterioration ... and a Wave of Hysterical Terror Denounced by the Phalanges.” Al-Aamal, Sunday 7th December 1975, Edition 36. Number 9096.
  4. “56 Bodies and 300 Kidnapped. The Killing Hysteria Sweeps Beirut.” An-Nahar, Sunday 7th December 1975. Edition 43. Number 12682.
  5. “The Left Suspend their Membership in the Coordination Committee and Accuse Certain Kataeb Leaders of Leading the Massacre.” An-Nahar, Monday 8th December 1975.
  6. “The Day of Madness 80 bodies and 350 kidnapped.” Al Anwar, Sunday 7th December 1975. Edition 17, Number 5412.
  7. Salman, Talal. Ed. “The Second Day of the Kataeb’s Massacre: 50 Bodies and 45 Kidnapped FP.” As-Safir, Monday 8th December 1975. Number 613.
  8. Al-Kassis, George. Diaries of Witness, Loyalty to the Heroes of the Lebanese Resistance and the Truth's Trust V.1. Beirut: Dar Sa’er Al-Mashreq, 2018.
  9. Document of the Lebanese War. Dar Al Sayyad, 1977. V.1.
  10. Freiha, George. With Bashir Gemayel: Memories and Memoires. Beirut: Dar Sa’er Al-Mashreq, 2019.
  11. Hayek, George. Bashir Gemayel: History in a Man, Beirut: The Author, 2009.
  12. Khawand, Massoud. Encyclopedia of the Lebanese War: Memory of a Nation and People. Ed. Nada Eid. V. 1. Beirut: Universal Company, 2006.
  13. Meshaalani, Maroun. The Cross of War: From the Deep of Darkness to the Heavenly Light. Beirut: Gabriel Gemayel, 2018.
  14. Saadeh, Joseph. I am the Victim and the Perpetrator is I. Lebanon: Dar Aljadid, 2005.
  15. Tamimova, May. “The Black Saturday Massacre of 1975: the discomfort of assembling the Lebanese civil war narrative.” In Contemporary Levant 2018.
  16. Traboulsi, Fawaz. The Blood of Two Brothers. Beirut: El-Rayyes Books, 2017.
  17. Younes, Emad. Series of the Main Documents of the Lebanese Crisis 1973:The Main Documents for the Lebanese People. V.1. Beirut, 1986.