Black Saturday

Exploring different perspectives on pivotal events early in the Lebanese Civil War. Watch a visual version in two parts: here and here. A trailer for a longer documentary, to be published, can be viewed here.

How to Read This Article

Below, we explore two different narratives concerning the events of Friday 5 and Saturday 6 December 1975, known as the events of Black Saturday. One narrative describes the perspective of the National Movement, a coalition of left-wing and Muslim groups, the other describes the perspective of the Lebanese Front, a coalition of mainly Christian groups. Both perspectives are based on archival sources and interviews with key actors and victims of the time, and validated by current representatives of the relevant parties.For security reasons, a single letter is substituted for the names of primary sources. The narratives thus represent the dominant perspective on each side. For more information on the research process behind this article, see here.

You will have the ability to switch between these perspectives using buttons under the "Choose a Narrative" tab either on the left hand side or above the narratives, depending on your device. Significant disagreements between the two narratives are highlighted and clicking or hovering reveals a short explanation of the other side's point of view. Clicking on the alternative explanation transports the reader to the relevant contested section in the other narrative.

Background

Since 1948, there had been a significant presence of hundreds of thousands of Palestinian refugees in Lebanon. They resided in camps like Tal Al-Zaatar, Jisr El-Basha, Karantina, and Dbaye, and many were involved in an armed struggle against Israel to regain their former lands. With the Cairo Agreement of November 1969, the Lebanese Armed Forces ceded control over the Palestinian camps to the Palestinian Armed Struggle Command. This drove already mounting tensions to a breaking point, as some Christian groups responded politically and militarily to what they considered an infringement on Lebanese sovereignty, while many leftist and Muslim groups supported the Palestinian cause in their allegiance to a broader Arab nationalist ideal. Thus, an armed struggle began.

April 1975 is often identified as the beginning of the Lebanese Civil War, associated with the infamous incident of the Ain Al-Rummaneh bus. Over the subsequent months, the conflict developed to involve a confrontation between mainly right-wing Christian groups of the Lebanese Front and its allies,The Lebanese Front included the Kataeb Party, the National Liberal Party, the Guardians of the Cedars, Tanzim, and was allied with a Christian group that splintered from the Lebanese Army under the name of the Free Lebanon Army. and leftist and Muslim groups of the National Movement and its allies.The Lebanese National Movement included the Progressive Socialist Party, the Communist Party, the Communist Action Organization, the Syrian Social Nationalist Party, the Ba'ath Party, the Independent Nasserite Movement (Al-Mourabitoun), the Popular Nasserist Organization, and was allied with the Palestine Liberation Organization, and a splinter group of the Lebanese Army known as the Lebanese Arab Army. Black Saturday proved to be a major escalation and sectarianization of this conflict.


Questions for Reflection

  1. Is there a narrative you identify more with? If so, which one, and why? If not, why not?
  2. If you identify more with one narrative, how does the other make you feel?
  3. If you could have advised Joseph Saadeh on the morning of Black Saturday when he discovered his son had been murdered (see Lebanese Front narrative), what would you have said to him?
  4. What sort of feelings is Black Saturday manifesting, and which of these still need to be addressed today?
  5. During Black Saturday, some Christian militia members are known to have saved Muslims from being massacred, and vice-versa. How does that make you change your opinion about these events?

Resources

  1. Download the National Movement and Lebanese Front narratives in text form.
  2. Download an infographic concisely visualizing the events and highlighting the main differences between the narratives.
  3. Watch a visual version of the two narratives: the Fanar incident on Friday and Black Saturday.